Betts Recruiting

Get our new Compensation Guide for 2024!


Key Questions to Ask When Hiring a Customer Success Manager 

The Betts Team
May 26, 2023

In our previous blog post, we discussed the key questions to ask when hiring an account executive to ensure you find the perfect fit for your sales team. Now, let’s shift our focus to another critical role in driving business growth and customer satisfaction: the Customer Success Manager (CSM). A CSM plays a vital role in nurturing relationships with clients, ensuring their success with your products or services, and driving retention and upsell opportunities. In this blog post, we will explore the responsibilities of a CSM, the key skills to look for when hiring, and the essential questions to ask during the interview process.

The Role of a Customer Success Manager:

  • Relationship Management: Customer Success Managers are responsible for building and maintaining strong relationships with clients. They act as the primary point of contact and advocate for customers within the organization, ensuring their needs are understood and addressed.
  • Onboarding and Adoption: CSMs play a crucial role in guiding customers through the onboarding process, helping them understand the value of your products or services, and facilitating their successful adoption. They provide training, resources, and support to ensure clients achieve their desired outcomes.
  • Customer Health Monitoring: CSMs closely monitor customer health and engagement metrics to proactively identify any potential issues or areas for improvement. They use this information to develop strategies and interventions to drive customer success and prevent churn.
  • Upsell and Expansion Opportunities: CSMs are responsible for identifying upsell and expansion opportunities within their assigned accounts. They collaborate with sales teams to uncover additional business needs and work towards expanding the relationship and revenue generated from existing clients.
  • Customer Advocacy: CSMs act as advocates for their customers, ensuring their feedback is heard and incorporated into product development and improvement processes. They gather customer insights and communicate them effectively to internal teams to drive customer-centric decision-making.

Key Skills and Qualities of a Customer Success Manager:

  • Customer-Focused Mindset: A successful CSM is deeply committed to customer success and satisfaction. They genuinely care about the well-being and achievements of their clients and are willing to go above and beyond to ensure their success.
  • Strong Communication and Relationship-Building Skills: CSMs must possess excellent communication skills, both verbal and written. They should be able to articulate complex ideas clearly, listen actively to customer needs, and build trust and rapport with clients.
  • Problem-Solving and Analytical Abilities: CSMs encounter various challenges and obstacles while supporting their clients. They need to be adept at analyzing situations, identifying root causes, and finding creative solutions to address customer issues effectively.
  • Product and Industry Knowledge: CSMs should have a deep understanding of your products or services and the industry in which your company operates. This knowledge enables them to provide valuable guidance and support to customers, helping them maximize the value they derive from your offerings.
  • Proactive and Goal-Oriented Approach: A proactive mindset is crucial for a CSM. They should be able to anticipate customer needs, identify potential risks, and take proactive measures to ensure customer success. They should also be goal-oriented and driven to achieve both individual and team targets.

Key Questions to Ask When Hiring a Customer Success Manager:

  1. Experience with Customer Success: Begin by asking the candidate about their overall experience in customer success roles. Inquire about the industries they have worked in and the types of customers they have managed. Look for alignment between their past experience and your target market.

  2. Onboarding and Adoption Strategies: Ask the candidate to describe their approach to onboarding new customers and driving successful adoption. Look for their ability to develop personalized onboarding plans and their understanding of key milestones and success metrics

  3. Handling Challenging Customer Situations: Customer Success Managers often encounter challenging situations with customers, such as escalations, dissatisfaction, or roadblocks to success. Ask the candidate to share an example of a difficult customer situation they handled and how they resolved it. Look for their ability to navigate conflicts, diffuse tensions, and find mutually beneficial solutions.

  4. Customer Health Monitoring and Metrics: Inquire about the candidate’s experience in monitoring customer health and engagement metrics. Ask them to explain the key metrics they track and how they use that data to drive customer success. Look for their ability to proactively identify risks and opportunities based on data insights.

  5. Collaborative Skills: Customer Success Managers need to collaborate closely with various internal teams, including sales, product, and support. Ask the candidate to describe their experience working collaboratively with cross-functional teams and how they ensure alignment and effective communication. Look for their ability to navigate internal dynamics and foster strong teamwork.

  6. Upsell and Expansion Strategies: Customer Success Managers play a crucial role in driving upsell and expansion opportunities with existing customers. Ask the candidate to share their approach to identifying upsell opportunities and how they work with sales teams to pursue those opportunities. Look for their ability to uncover customer needs and present compelling value propositions.

  7. Customer Advocacy and Feedback: A key responsibility of Customer Success Managers is to gather customer feedback and advocate for their needs within the organization. Ask the candidate how they have effectively gathered and communicated customer feedback in their previous roles. Look for their ability to articulate customer insights and influence internal decision-making.

  8. Continuous Learning and Improvement: Customer Success is a dynamic field that requires continuous learning and improvement. Ask the candidate how they stay updated on industry trends, best practices, and new technologies related to customer success. Look for their passion for personal and professional growth and their commitment to staying ahead in the field.

  9. Metrics and Success Stories:Inquire about the key metrics the candidate has been measured against in their previous customer success roles. Ask them to share success stories or achievements that highlight their impact on customer outcomes and business results. Look for their ability to connect their actions to tangible outcomes. Additionally, consider discussing metrics such as retention rates, the candidate’s book of business, notable accounts, and the measurement methods used in their previous roles. Assess their strategies for improving customer retention, their capacity to handle diverse customer portfolios, their success with high-profile accounts, familiarity with metrics like customer retention rates and ARR, and their responsibilities in areas such as onboarding, QBRS, renewals upsells, adoption, demos, NPS, and customer health.

  10. Cultural Fit: Customer Success Managers need to align with your company’s values, culture, and customer-centric approach. Ask the candidate about their understanding of your company’s culture and values and how they believe they would contribute to that culture. Look for their passion for your company’s mission and their ability to adapt to your organization’s way of doing things.

Hiring the right Customer Success Manager is essential for driving customer satisfaction, retention, and expansion. By asking the key questions mentioned above, you can assess a candidate’s experience, skills, and qualities necessary for success in this critical role. Remember to evaluate not only their technical abilities but also their customer-centric mindset, communication skills, and collaborative approach. With the right Customer Success Manager on board, you can ensure long-term success and value for your customers.

Introducing Betts Connect: Your Solution for Finding the Right Hires

Are you currently in search of your next Customer Success Manager? Look no further than Betts Connect, the go-to-market recruiting platform that is revolutionizing the hiring process. Powered by recruiters with extensive industry expertise, Connect offers a vast network of vetted sales, marketing, and customer success professionals actively seeking their next opportunity. By leveraging this platform, you can significantly reduce your time to hire, save costs, and allocate more resources to your growth strategy. The best part? Our clients consistently experience a return on investment in less than three months. Stay Ahead with Betts Connect